FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE:
Contact:
Kristina Baum – 202.224.6176
Donelle Harder – 202.224.1282
Inhofe
Asks EPA to Respond to Request for Reversal on Rule Disincentivizing NGVs
WASHINGTON,
DC – U.S. Sen. Jim Inhofe (R-Okla.), chairman of the Senate Committee on
Environment and Public Works (EPW), today sent a letter to Environmental
Protection Agency (EPA) Adm. Gina McCarthy to request an update regarding EPA’s
consideration of the VNG/NGVAmerica petition requesting relief for natural gas
vehicles (NGV) under EPA’s light-duty vehicle greenhouse gas rule that was finalized
on August 28, 2012.
In the
letter, Inhofe highlights how EPA’s rule curtails incentives for the purchase
of NGVs after model year 2016, creating a clear bias in favor of electric
vehicles (EV). In Dec. 2012, VNG and NGVAmerica filed a petition
requesting this rule be reversed, yet EPA has taken no action to date on the
request.
In the
letter, Chairman Inhofe writes, “I request a status update regarding EPA’s
consideration of the VNG/NGVAmerica petition and to urge a prompt decision
granting the relief requested in the petition. The threshold established
by EPA is contrary to the current automobile industry practice and serves no
purpose other than to unnecessarily hinder the market development of
NGVs. All of the dual-fuel NGVs currently available and announced for
model year 2015 provide twice the range on gasoline as they do on natural gas,
but still provide a minimum of 150 miles on natural gas. There is no
justification for preventing these vehicles from taking advantage of the utility
factor calculations in measuring greenhouse gas emissions.”
In the
letter, Inhofe provides a rebuttal to EPA’s decision to phased out the
incentive for NGVs due to it not being as much of a “game changing” technology
as EVs. He highlights the following three reasons why natural gas is an
indispensable alternative when considering the importance of the market for
light trucks:
·
Natural gas is the only commercially available alternative fuel for light
trucks, which make up more than half the market and
are increasingly popular with low gasoline prices.
·
EVs are limited to small cars (due to battery weight and cost), less than half
of the market.
·
NGV emissions are already approximately 25% lower than gasoline and can be
reduced further by blending with biogas and/or hydrogen.
Inhofe continues,
“While EVs may be ‘game-changers’ in their own right for cars, NGVs are
clearly a game-changer for the light trucks that make up more than half of new
vehicle sales. Light trucks account for over half of petroleum consumption and emissions and generally have lower fuel economy than
cars. By allowing NGVs to continue receiving incentives, EPA will ensure
that all clean fuel alternatives are developed for all types of vehicles – and
not reserved for EPA’s ideal small EVs.”
Background:
On
December 19, 2014, a provision authored by Inhofe and then-Sen. Carl Levin
(D-Mich.) was signed into law that incentivizes the production of NGVs. The
provision was included in the National Defense Authorization Act for fiscal
year 2015, which passed
congress on Dec. 12. Prior to the provision, the law
allowed automakers to earn credits for compliance with the Corporate Average
Fuel Economy (CAFE) program by producing alternative fuel dual-fueled vehicles,
and credits are subject to a cap. Automakers earned the majority of their
allowed credits by producing E85 Flex-Fuel vehicles, leaving none left for
NGVs. The Inhofe-Levin provision modified the program by removing the credit
cap for natural gas dual-fueled vehicles.
The full text of the letter is as follows:
March _, 2014
The Honorable Gina
McCarthy
Administrator
Environmental
Protection Agency
1200 Pennsylvania
Avenue NW
Room 1101A
Washington, DC 20460
Re: Petition for Reconsideration of Final Rule
published in the Federal Register
October 15, 2012, Docket Nos. EPA-HQ-OAR-2010-0799 and NHTSA 2010-0131 (2017
and Later Model Year Light-Duty Vehicle Greenhouse Gas Emissions and Corporate
Average Fuel Economy Standards)
Dear Ms. McCarthy:
Since the Alternative
Motor Fuels Act of 1988, natural gas vehicles (NGVs) have been awarded
incentives under federal Corporate Average Fuel Economy (CAFE) rules. However,
Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA’s) light-duty vehicle greenhouse gas
(GHG) rules established in the above-referenced docket curtail some incentives
after model year 2016. By contrast, the analogous incentives for electric
vehicles (EVs) are extended through 2025, creating a bias clearly in favor of
EVs over NGVs.
In 2014, I worked to
pass legislation to address, inter alia, the minimum driving range for
alternative fuel vehicles. However, in the above-referenced docket, EPA
required that dual-fuel NGVs: (1) have a minimum ratio of natural gas range to
gasoline range of 2.0; and (2) are designed so that gasoline can only be used
when the CNG tank is empty[1] in order to take advantage of utility factor calculations in
measuring greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions and CAFE. It is my understanding
that VNG and NGVAmerica filed a petition for reconsideration with EPA in
December 2012 urging reversal of this decision, and it is my further
understanding that EPA has not taken any action on this petition.
I request a status
update regarding EPA’s consideration of the VNG/NGVAmerica petition and to urge
a prompt decision granting the relief requested in the petition. The
threshold established by EPA is contrary to the current automobile industry
practice and serves no purpose other than to unnecessarily hinder the market
development of NGVs. All of the dual-fuel NGVs currently available and
announced for model year 2015 provide twice the range on gasoline as they do on
natural gas, but still provide a minimum of 150 miles on natural gas.
There is no justification for preventing these vehicles from taking advantage
of the utility factor calculations in measuring greenhouse gas emissions.
Similarly, under
EPA’s GHG rules, both EVs and NGVs are temporarily credited as generating
greater reductions in emissions than they do in the real world in order to
encourage automakers to adopt these new technologies. However, EV
incentives will be in effect through 2025 while NGV incentives will be phased
out in 2016.
EPA justified its
decision to phase out the emissions incentive for NGVs well before it phases
out the incentive for EVs on the grounds that NGVs are not as much of a
“game-changing” technology as EVs. In actuality, natural gas is not only
a game-changer but an indispensable alternative when you consider the
importance of the market for light trucks (larger vehicles such as pickups,
minivans, and SUVs):
·
Natural gas is the only commercially available alternative fuel for light
trucks, which make up more than half the market and are increasingly popular
with low gasoline prices
·
EVs are limited to small cars (due to battery weight and cost), less than half
of the market
·
NGV emissions are already approximately 25% lower than gasoline and can be
reduced further by blending with biogas and/or hydrogen
While EVs may be
“game-changers” in their own right for cars, NGVs are clearly a game-changer
for the light trucks that make up more than half of new vehicle sales. Light
trucks account for over half of petroleum consumption and emissions and
generally have lower fuel economy than cars. By allowing NGVs to continue
receiving incentives, EPA will ensure that all clean fuel alternatives are
developed for alltypes of vehicles – and not reserved for EPA’s ideal small
EVs.
I
recognize that one of your concerns may be that consumers who purchase
dual-fuel NGVs will not use the alternative fuel and will rely instead on
gasoline. This concern is unfounded. This issue is a real one in
the flex-fuel vehicle market; very few consumers ever run their flex-fuel
vehicles on ethanol. Dual-fuel NGVs are different. Automakers do
not generally charge a premium for flex-fuel vehicles compared to their
gasoline-only equivalents; as such there is no ongoing financial incentive (or
disincentive) to a specific fuel. Dual-fuel NGVs, however, often see
upcharges ranging from $5,000 to $10,000 per vehicle – a function of the
necessary equipment add-ons. Knowing this, the only economically sound
reason to purchase a dual-fuel NGV is to take advantage of lower natural gas
fuel prices, irrespective of the vehicle’s range on that fuel. Consumers
who have dual-fuel NGVs use natural gas as their primary fuel, and EPA’s
regulations should credit automakers accordingly.
I appreciate your
attention to and prompt resolution of this matter.
Sincerely,
_____________________
James M. Inhofe
Chairman
###