March 18, 2015

NEWS: Myth/Fact on The Frank R. Lautenberg Chemical Safety for the 21st Century Act

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE:
Contact:
Kristina Baum – 202.224.6176
Donelle Harder – 202.224.1282 

 

Myth/Fact on The
Frank R. Lautenberg Chemical Safety for the 21st Century Act

WASHINGTON,
DC – U.S. Senator Jim Inhofe (R-Okla.), chairman of
the U.S. Senate Environment and Public Works (EPW) Committee, questioned
witnesses today
at the legislative hearing entitled, “Frank R.
Lautenberg Chemical Safety for the 21st Century Act”
(S.697). 
Witnesses included Jim Jones, Assistant Administrator for the Office of the
Chemical Safety and Pollution Prevention for the U.S. Environmental Protection
Agency (EPA);  Richard Denison, Senior Scientist for the Environmental
Defense Fund (EDF);  Edward McCabe, Senior Vice President and Chief
Medical Officer for the March of Dimes Foundation;  Lynn Goldman, Dean of
the Milken Institute School of Public Health at The George Washington
University;  Ken Cook, President and Co-founder of the Environmental
Working Group (EWG);  and The Honorable Brian E. Frosh, Attorney General
for the State of Maryland. Sens. David
Vitter (R-La.)
and Tom
Udall (D-N.M.)
, coauthors of the bill, were present and provided valuable
input on the path forward for this historical piece of legislation.

 

From the hearing, the following myths and facts emerged to set the
record straight on S.697:

 

MYTH: S. 697 will not address
asbestos.

FACT: S. 697 takes a very clear
“worst-first” approach.  The bill gives EPA the authority and discretion
to immediately prioritize and begin a safety evaluation of asbestos or other
chemicals of high concern.

Furthermore,
S. 697 removes the two procedural hurdles in current law that prevented EPA
from regulating asbestos in the past: the requirement that cost benefit
analysis be included in any safety determination; and the requirement that EPA
adopt the least burdensome regulatory requirement. 

 

MYTH: S. 697 is worse than current
law.

FACT: S. 697 will make grant EPA a
number of new authorities making oversight of chemicals stronger, more
timely,  and removing barriers that have made it difficult for EPA to act
by enacting significant changes including:

·        
Requiring
the first-ever systematic review of all chemicals in commerce.  Current
law  grandfathered thousands of chemicals already on the market when TSCA
was enacted, and the vast majority of them have not been reviewed for safety.

·        
Making
it easier for EPA to request additional testing or safety data from manufacturers. 
Current law requires EPA to demonstrate an unreasonable risk of harm before it
can require more testing and data, a hurdle that is often too high without the
very data the agency is seeking. 

·        
Ensuring
that safety evaluations of chemicals are only based on health and safety
information.  Current law requires EPA to consider costs and benefits when
determining if a chemical is safe, a factor that should be irrelevant to a
safety determination.

·        
Setting
hard deadlines for EPA action.  Current law does not hold EPA to
deadlines, contributing to lengthy delays and years of inaction.

·        
Strengthening
protections for the most vulnerable including infants, children, pregnant
women, workers and the elderly.  Current law does not mandate that EPA to
consider exposures to these vulnerable groups.

 

MYTH: Supporters of S. 697 want to
slash the EPA chemicals budget and do not proved the Agency with the resources
they need to carry out the federal management of chemicals.

FACT: S. 697 includes a new user fees
provision that gives EPA the authority to add additional resources up to 25% of
the funds they get from Congress.  These user fees can be used for any
number of activities to help better implement the law including prioritizing
existing chemicals, conducting and completing safety assessments and
determinations, and any necessary regulatory rulemakings.

 

MYTH: S. 697 strips states of
authority to regulate the most dangerous chemicals, even when EPA has done
nothing.

FACT: The only time EPA action ever
impacts existing state restrictions is after a full assessment and
determination on a chemical.  Where the chemical is found to meet the
safety standard or after a national federal regulation is in place if a
chemical is determined not to meet the safety standard.  States can
continue to implement new regulations for low priority chemicals and are only
preempted from imposing new restrictions on the select uses being reviewed for
high priority chemicals after reviews are underway and a scope is clearly
defined by the EPA.  States can also apply for waivers that would allow
them to restrict high priority chemicals during reviews as well as from EPA
final rules.  This process is designed to create consistent national regulations
of chemicals which are of the greatest concern in order to protect all
Americans.  Moreover S. 697 also grandfathers
in all actions taken by states to regulate chemicals prior to January 1, 2015
regardless of future EPA decisions as well as California’s Prop 65.

 

Background:

At
today’s legislative hearing for The Frank R. Lautenberg Chemical Safety for
the 21st Century Act
,  EPA confirmed the bill is consistent
with all six of their guiding principles for TSCA reform.  In addition,
three renowned public health experts all concluded the bill was stronger than
current law and significantly increased public health protections including for
those most vulnerable like children and pregnant women.  The witnesses
also highlighted the need for a stronger TSCA law, as opposed to a stronger
TSCA bill, acknowledging a bipartisan compromise is essential to actually
achieving reform.  S.697 touts strong bipartisan support in the U.S.
Senate along with the support of the Environmental Defense Fund, eight state
attorneys general, three former EPA General Counsel, and a former Assistant
U.S. Attorney General.  Without bipartisan support, the current antiquated
law from 1976 could not be updated leaving a vast majority of the American
public with little to no public health protections.

 

###

Print 
Email 
Share 
Share