March 23, 2015

Inhofe Calls to Question White House Hire from the Environmental Defense Fund

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE:

Contact:

Kristina Baum – 202.224.6176

Donelle Harder – 202.224.1282

 

Inhofe Calls to Question White House Hire from the Environmental
Defense Fund

 

WASHINGTON, DC – U.S. Sen. Jim Inhofe (R-Okla.), chairman of the
Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works (EPW), today sent a letter to
the White House Counsel, W. Neil Eggleston, questioning the hiring of Megan
Ceronsky as a senior advisor to
President Obama in the White House Office of Energy and Climate
Change.  Ceronsky was previously a senior official at the Environmental
Defense Fund (EDF) where she played an instrumental role in shaping rules to
push forward the implementation of the
president’s Climate Action Plan. 


 

“The
recent news that the White House has hired a senior official from the
Environmental Defense Fund (EDF), an environmental group that played an
integral role in shaping the rules, to ‘help push forward the implementation of
the
president’s Climate Action Plan,’ is especially alarming,” said
Chairman Inhofe. “It appears highly inappropriate to have Ms. Ceronsky serve
in any capacity interacting with EPA or otherwise involved in the development
of these rules, considering her prior legal representation and advocacy on
behalf of EDF before EPA on these very same matters.”

 

According to the Standards of Ethical Conduct for Employees of the
Executive Branch, 5 C.F.R. 2635.502, federal employees are not to participate
in particular matters in which the employee previously represented a party in
the matter and where a reasonable person would question the employee’s impartiality. 
State bar requirements also address the requirements of an attorney to act on
behalf of their clients and the possible need for disqualification to avoid
conflicts of interest related to their work for former clients. 

 

The letter to White House Counsel Eggleston seeks information
about whether Ms. Ceronsky will be recused from interacting with her former
employer, the  Environmental Defense Fund, and copies of her
communications with the Environmental Protection Agency, among other topics.

 

 

The full text of
the letter is also below:

 

 

March
23, 2015

 

Mr. W. Neil Eggleston

Counsel to the President

Office the White House Counsel

The White House

1600 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW

Washington, D.C.  20500

 

 

Dear Mr. Eggleston:

 

The U.S. Senate Committee on
Environment and Public Works (EPW) has been conducting oversight of the U.S.
Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA) proposed climate regulations as part of
the President’s Climate Action Plan.  These proposed rules are based on
questionable legal theories and would have a devastating impact on the nation’s
economy and electricity reliability while doing very little to curb global
carbon emissions. 

 

There is concern that key
environmental activists have had an outsized influence in developing the rules
compared to states and ordinary Americans who will ultimately bear the burden
of these actions.  The recent news that the White House has hired a senior
official from the Environmental Defense Fund (EDF), an environmental group that
played an integral role in shaping the rules, to “help push forward the
implementation of the President’s Climate Action Plan,”[2]
is especially alarming. 

 

The official in question,
Megan Ceronsky, was EDF’s Director of Regulatory Policy and Senior Attorney
before she was hired in January 2015 as a senior advisor in the White House
Office of Energy and Climate Change.[3] 
This appointment is particularly concerning in light of Ms. Ceronsky’s
representation of EDF in litigation seeking issuance of these very rules, as
well as her participation in EPA’s development of these rules themselves. 
Accordingly, your cooperation is requested to better understanding Ms.
Ceronsky’s appointment and future role to address concerns about Ms. Ceronsky’s
impartiality and to ensure the utmost level of integrity in the regulatory
process being overseen by the White House.  

 

EDF was a party to the
initial litigation against EPA over new source performance standards for new
and modified power plants (NSPS) and emission guidelines for existing power
plants (ESPS) under section 111 of the Clean Air Act.[4] 
The parties reached an initial settlement in December 2010[5]
and agreed to a revised settlement in June 2011.[6] 
As counsel of record for EDF, Ms. Ceronsky was a signatory to the revised
settlement, which required EPA to propose the NSPS by September 30, 2011.[7]  This extension was made without
any opportunity for public comment. 

 

EPA failed to meet the
revised settlement deadline to propose the NSPS, and documents obtained by the
Committee reveal that Ms. Ceronsky, in fact, participated in negotiations with
EPA in October 2011 to extend the deadlines and hold the litigation in
forbearance.[8]  EPA initially
proposed the NSPS on March 27, 2012.[9] 
A year later, on March 27, 2013, Ms. Ceronsky sent a notice of intent to sue to
the EPA, on behalf of EDF and other environmental groups for not finalizing the
NSPS.[10]  Ms. Ceronsky’s was also part
of a follow-up letter on the same topic sent by another EDF attorney on April
15, 2013.[11] 

 

Before EPA finalized the NSPS rule, President Obama
released his Climate Action Plan in June 2013,[12]
and directed EPA to re-propose the NSPS by September 20, 2013, and to finalize
it in a timely fashion thereafter. [13]
The President also directed EPA to issue a proposal for modified and existing
power plants by June 1, 2014, and to finalize that rule within a year. [14]  EPA subsequently re-proposed
the NSPS in January 2014[15] and
proposed the ESPS in June 2014.[16]

 

Ms. Ceronsky was invited to an August 29, 2013, meeting at
EPA headquarters, along with the Natural Resources Defense Council
(NRDC),another environmental activist  group involved in drafting the
rules, to discuss outreach for the rules.[17] 
On December 10, 2013, Ms. Ceronsky sent a white paper advocating EPA’s legal
authority to require carbon capture and sequestration under the NSPS[18] and a related blog posting to an
attorney in the EPA Office of General Counsel.[19] 
Notably she said:  “I wanted to share the attached blog and legal analysis
defending the proposed Carbon Pollution Standards for new power plants from the
attacks leveled by the House Energy and Commerce leadership, which went up
Friday.”[20]  EPA even cited
a second white paper she co-authored  with another EDF attorney in the
Agency’s legal memorandum for the ESPS.[21]

 

Moreover, Ms. Ceronsky is
included on emails sent between the NRDC and senior EPA officials concerning
meeting requests to discuss the ESPS.[22] 
At a minimum, we are aware she also participated in meetings on August 26,
2014,[23] September 10, 2014,[24] and October 21, 2014,[25] and a conference call on October 30,
2014,[26] with EPA to discuss the proposed
rules. 

 

According to the Standards
of Ethical Conduct for Employees of the Executive Branch, 5 C.F.R. 2635.502,
federal employees are not to participate in particular matters in which the
employee previously represented a party in the matter and where a reasonable
person would question the employee’s impartiality.  State bar requirements
also address the requirements of an attorney to act on behalf of their clients
and the possible need for disqualification to avoid conflicts of interest
related to their work for former clients. 

 

It appears highly
inappropriate to have Ms. Ceronsky serve in any capacity interacting with EPA
or otherwise involved in the development of these rules, considering her prior
legal representation and advocacy on behalf of EDF before EPA on these very
same matters.  It is akin to having the fox watch the henhouse. 

 

Given these concerns, it is
important that Congress and the American people have confidence that Obama
Administration officials are acting with impartiality and in the best interest
of the American people, in accordance with federal conflict of interest and
ethics laws, and not in any way advocating in favor of former employers or
clients.

 

In order to better
understand the circumstances surrounding Ms. Ceronsky’s work on the Climate
Action Plan and her adherence to federal ethics laws, please provide the
following information and documents no later than [one week]:

 

1.      
A copy of any financial disclosure forms, ethics agreements,
screening arrangements, recusals, and/or conflict of interest waivers
concerning Ms. Ceronsky; and

 

2.      
Copies of all communications between Ms. Ceronsky and the EPA, the
Department of Energy, the Department of Justice, and/or the Council on
Environmental Quality concerning regulation of new, modified, and existing
power plants pursuant to section 111 of the Clean Air Act.

 

 

I look forward to your
prompt response to this request.  Please have your staff contact the
Committee on Environment and Public Works at (202) 224-6176 with any questions
concerning this request.

 

 

 

 

                                               
Sincerely,

 

 

 

 

                                               
James M. Inhofe,

                                               
Chairman

###

 

Print 
Email 
Share 
Share