It might seem odd that local agencies responsible for protecting and improving soil and water would oppose new federal clean-water rules.

But that might be the official stance of the Delaware Soil and Water Conservation District when it meets soon to discuss the issue and document its concerns.

And Delaware County commissioners, developers and farmers also worry about the expanded definition of waterways by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Federal regulators that previously had jurisdiction over “navigable waterways” will, beginning on Aug. 28, oversee tiny tributaries, backyard streams and even dry creek beds.

As clean water and pesticide and fertilizer runoff have become major problems in Ohio, anger has surfaced from some governments, conservation groups and farmers about the changes.

“We’re very much in favor of clean water,” said Brad Ross, spokesman for the Delaware conservation district. “The reason we struggle with this is that, in our estimation, it’s an over-reach by the federal government that is cumbersome and unnecessary.”

Proponents argue that previously unregulated land, even if dry for much of the year, eventually cleanses itself of pollutants into streams and reservoirs. The buildup of organic matter can create toxic-algae blooms and dead zones in reservoirs and high nitrate levels.

In severe cases, lakes have been closed for swimming, and drinking water has been banned.

Farmers and land developers say they also want safe water but argue that federal permits are a growing burden to their operations.

Farmers already are vigilant about contaminant runoff, Ross said. “They’re right there on the ground, living and breathing (environmentalism) every day. They don’t want to do anything that’s going to harm the land or pollute the ground they’re using.”

The fifth-generation Skinner family has run the 2,000-acre Hardscrabble Farms just east of the city of Delaware for more than a century and is unsure which ponds, mostly dry creeks and ditches might now be subject to expanded review.

“They say they’re not going to cover puddles, but the wording in the law doesn’t say they can’t,” said Gary Skinner, 71. “Actually, we don’t need it in the law if they’re not going to enforce it.

“There’s so many regulations and permits and fees anymore it makes it hard to run your business.”

More than a dozen states, including Ohio, agree, and have filed lawsuits opposing the changes. “It’s an outright expansion” of jurisdiction for both the Ohio EPA and the Army Corps of Engineers, said Dan Tierney, spokesman for Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine. “It clearly takes in things that are dry land.”

Homebuilders also are opposed.

“If you own land, you’re now restricted in what you can do with it, unless you contact the EPA,” said Vince Squillace, executive vice president of the 4,200-member Ohio Home Builders Association. “Depending on their decision, you may not be able to use your land anymore.”

Delaware County Commissioner Gary Merrell supports a U.S. Senate bill that would revert the water rules back to navigable.

“Let’s take a deep breath and look at this and make sure we don’t have any unintended consequences,” he said.

Not all officials think the new standard is burdensome.

“It shouldn’t change how we do business,” said Jennifer Fish, director of the Franklin Soil and Water Conservation District. “We don’t see how it changes how water quality is protected in Ohio. The Ohio EPA makes the bulk of the rules.

“Definitions that had been considered overly broad are now more scientifically based,” she said.

The Sierra Club of Columbus agreed, saying the rules provide “desperately needed clarity.”

But Joe Cornely, of the Ohio Farm Bureau Federation, said the change runs counter to the original intent of the 1972 Clean Water Act and creates “de facto control over normal everyday farming practices” such as fertilizing and cultivating or conservation.

“The latest version of the ruling is what we call mission creep. Give them an inch and they take 10 miles,” Cornely said.

“How do you plan for the future when you don’t know what the EPA is going to tell you the future is going to look like?”

Brian Skinner, who tends to the corn and soybean fields with his father, worries about the new oversight.

“It does away with the American spirit,” he said. “Most people in our industry do the right thing day in and day out. The more you let the individual do their job to the best of their ability, 99 percent of those people are probably going to do a better job than you expect.”