On Thursday, the
If the past is prologue, we can be certain that this new ozone standard will be no different, imposing draconian economic costs on states and counties across the country.
In 2008, the Bush administration set the standard for ozone at 75 parts per billion (ppb). This standard, a reduction from the 84 ppb set in 1997, was viewed at the time as quite stringent, and counties faced major challenges in meeting it. Now, the Obama administration has set the ozone standard at 70 ppb — a requirement that will push counties all over the country out of attainment, causing extensive economic turmoil.
When a county is in nonattainment, business as usual stops dead in its tracks. In order to build anything from factories to schools to hospitals, one must jump through a series of regulatory hoops, giving EPA veto power over any major projects. Not meeting the standard could keep companies from expanding and could even result in some industries electing to shut down their facilities and move out of state or even out of the country to places where there are fewer compliance restrictions, like
When I was mayor of Tulsa, Tulsa County was in nonattainment of the 1979 ozone NAAQS, so I have seen firsthand the economic impacts associated with the challenges of attainment and the legacy of EPA intervention that continues long after meeting the standard.
An additional consequence of a nonattainment designation that the administration frequently glosses over is its impact on transportation. A nonattainment county can lose federal highway and transit funds unless it can demonstrate that a project will not increase ozone emissions. A determination must be obtained from the
Despite EPA’s insistence that this rule is about public health, one state is essentially exempt from meeting any ozone standard: California. While claiming to be a leader in public health and insisting on more stringent standards for the rest of the country, Los Angeles County — by far the nation’s most populated — averages a staggering 109 ppb in ozone.
If EPA’s scare tactics were correct, we should be seeing an overwhelming public health crisis throughout the state of California that would make it unconscionable to continue allowing the state to remain so far out of compliance. Fortunately, these health impacts just haven’t materialized.
As a country, we have confronted and controlled the most common sources of ozone precursors, and our options are few and far between to handle what remains, which is mostly naturally occurring ozone and ozone transported from other countries such as Mexico. The rule exhibits a flippant disregard for rural and high-elevation communities that have no control over naturally occurring ground-level ozone. The administration should have given states and counties across the country the opportunity to fully meet the 2008 standard before implementing this frivolous and costly mandate.