The Senate stands poised to approve a resolution to kill the Obama administration’s contentious water rule today after opponents’ preferred measure to deal with the issue failed yesterday.
The resolution, a disapproval of the Waters of the U.S. rule, overcame a key procedural vote late yesterday afternoon thanks to expedited procedures under the Congressional Review Act that allow such a measure to be taken up with the support of only a simple majority.
Senators voted 55-43 to take up the measure, with three Democrats — Sens. Joe Donnelly of Indiana, Heidi Heitkamp of North Dakota and Joe Manchin of West Virginia — supporting and one Republican — Susan Collins of Maine — opposing.
The resolution is all but certain to pass later today but is headed only for a swift veto from President Obama, whose advisers issued another statement of administration policyyesterday afternoon.
The CRA resolution wasn’t the first choice of senators opposing the water rule. They had preferred to pass S. 1140, a measure from Sens. John Barrasso (R-Wyo.) and Donnelly that would have forced the current rule to be scrapped and would have set criteria for how a new rule should be developed and what streams and wetlands should and shouldn’t qualify for Clean Water Act protection under it.
That measure was filibustered by Democrats yesterday.
The vote hung on farm state Democrats who have been getting an earful from their agricultural constituents about the rule (E&ENews PM, Nov. 3).
That 11 of those Democrats opted to send a letter to the leaders of U.S. EPA and the Army Corps of Engineers warning the agencies to do a better job of addressing farmers’ concerns rather than allow the Barrasso measure to move forward left Senate Environment and Public Works Chairman James Inhofe (R-Okla.) fuming.
In a statement yesterday evening, Inhofe said that the open amendment process Republican leadership had promised on S. 1140 would have given them ample opportunity to provide that direction legislatively rather than in a letter to the agencies’ leaders.
“It is extremely disappointing that after failing to do their job to provide legislative clarity to the EPA on the regulation of our nation’s waters, Senate Democrats are writing a letter to the administration saying they reserve the right to do their jobs, simply at a later time,” he said.
“Proceeding to S. 1140 provided all Senators, including the 11 Senators authoring this letter, the opportunity to amend S. 1140 in an open process,” Inhofe said. “They then could have given EPA necessary direction on how to implement the Clean Water Act and the Waters of the U.S. rule. Legislating provides the legal clarity for the EPA to implement rules.”
The 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has put the water rule on hold but still has to decide whether it has jurisdiction over the stack of court challenges. If it sends the lawsuits to district court, the nationwide stay could be lifted.