House and Senate Republicans set out this week to probe the legal and economic consequences of the upcoming UN climate negotiations but will do so without administration witnesses.
Both the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee and the House Science, Space and Technology Committee will hold hearings Wednesday on the negotiations, set to kick off in Paris on Nov. 30.
French officials — including Prime Minister Manuel Valls and Foreign Minister Laurent Fabius — have said that there were no intentions to cancel or postpone the actual talks, despite Friday’s terrorist attacks that killed 129 and wounded more than 300 others.
Likewise, President Barack Obama, one of 117 heads of state and governments expected to attend the opening of the conference, has not changed plans.
The deal, based so far on international contributions from more than 150 nations, seeks to cut emissions enough to prevent global temperatures from rising 2 degrees Celsius above pre-industrial levels, the point where many scientists contend the worst effects of climate change would be irreversible.
The past week has highlighted some riffs among world powers. Secretary of State John Kerry, in remarks published by the Financial Times, said that the deal would not include legally binding reduction targets, nor would it be a treaty. But French President Francois Hollande fired back, contending that “”if the deal is not legally binding, there is no accord.”
The State Department was forced over the weekend to clarify Kerry’s remarks, saying the U.S. wants an agreement that has some binding and some non-binding elements. “The FT interview with Secretary Kerry may have been read to suggest that the U.S. supports a completely non-binding approach. That is not the case, and that is not Secretary Kerry’s position. Our position has not changed: the U.S. is pressing for an agreement that contains provisions both legally binding and non-legally binding,” the department told Politico.
If the deal is presented as a treaty, it would be subject to Senate approval, where it would meet a likely defeat under Republican leadership.
Republicans will look to play on those divides at the Wednesday hearings.
Senate Environment Chairman Sen. James Inhofe, R-Oka., weighed in on the back-and-forth between Kerry and France, saying it indicated that the Obama administration was willing to do anything to secure a “legacy” deal.
“This news, so close to the December negotiations, highlights both the reckless approach that the Obama administration has taken going into Paris and the discord which has ensued,” Inhofe said. “As he remains concerned with nothing but his legacy, the president is attempting to steamroll ahead with an emissions reduction target that he continues to fail to articulate and that the U.S. can neither reasonably achieve nor afford.”
While invitations were extended to administration witnesses, the testimony will be based on industry, legal and environmental experts. Representatives from the Manhattan Institute for Policy Research, the Chamber of Commerce, the Business Council for Sustainable Energy, and the World Resources Institute are among the witnesses for the Senate hearing.
The discussion is set to focus on the U.S. commitment to cut carbon emissions by up to 28 percent from 2005 levels, and reach that target by 2025. The cuts come through power plant carbon regulations, vehicle fuel efficiency standards, oil and gas methane reductions, efficiency programs and hydrofluorocarbon reductions.
On the House side, the committee will hear from representatives from NERA Economic Consulting, the Electric Reliability Council of Texas, the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative and the Cato Institute.
“There is a reason the president chose to bypass Congress in order to negotiate a climate deal on his own,” Chairman Lamar Smith, R-Texas, said. “The president’s plan gives control of U.S. energy policy to unelected United Nations officials.”
Republicans will also move on other fronts to fight the largest portion of the U.S. commitment: the Environmental Protection Agency’s Clean Power Plan.
On Tuesday and Wednesday, the House Energy and Commerce Committee will mark up and vote on a pair of Congressional Review Act resolutions from Rep. Ed Whitfield, R-Ky., to overturn the rules for new and existing fossil fuel-fired power plants.
The Senate may also vote this week on its own resolutions against the rules. This week would offer the Senate its last chance to voice disapproval of the regulations before the talks kick off, as Congress takes its Thanksgiving recess next week.
The House Natural Resources Committee also meets this week to discuss a bill from Chairman Rob Bishop, R-Utah, to reauthorize and reform the Land and Water Conservation Fund.
http://www.energyguardian.net/house-senate-republicans-set-assail-climate-deal
—
The Associated Press contributed to this report.